For all its bravado, America must be the most fearful country in the West. Insurance, immigration, (artificial) intelligence. A country kept in anxiety can’t be expected to stay healthy.
Great article. There's a huge issue with how people choose their health insurance, and the process seems designed to confuse the consumer. KFF found that 84% of Americans can't figure out what something will cost because they don't understand plan structures (deductibles, copays, allowed amounts, etc.).
Choosing the wrong employer-sponsored health plan can cost an individual thousands more in premiums and out-of-pocket costs. Across all our users, the wrong plan typically costs $4,339 more per year. And employers have an incentive to get everyone on the lowest-cost plan, whether or not it's right for the individual. Billions have been raised in recent years by companies that help steer employees toward the plans that cost employers the least (e.g., Nayya) or push them toward benefit programs unrelated to core insurance (e.g., Thatch).
We're building PlanStan (theplanstan.com), the first employee-aligned analysis tool, to solve this problem. It analyzes your options to find the one that actually costs you and your family the least. It uses hundreds of thousands of billing records to estimate usage and cost scenarios, then runs them through the real math and tax implications of each plan.
Next up for us is bringing more transparency to billing and pricing so people can be better consumers of healthcare.
Open market plans are always an option but there have a much worse tax treatment. Employer sponsored plans can be paid with pre tax dollars, but not open market plans.
We need to kill Employer Sponsored Insurance (ESI). Anything else is just rearranging deck chairs. Medicare For All (M4A) is a good slogan - but we already know that Medicare pricing won't work - so the slogan is just that. A slogan.
Pick your favorite AI agent and ask it to prepare a table. On the left (rows) have it list things like median household income, average marginal and effective tax rates at that median level as well as at other household income levels, say $70K, $125K, $300K, etc. Also rows for the % of taxes paid of the top 1%, 10% and, very importantly, the middle 50%; also ask what percent pay zero income tax. Along the right (the columns) have it list the US along with whatever countries you feel are providing better health care and lower cost. It will take you two minutes.
Spoiler alert: What you'll find is that, in those countries, everybody pays at nearly all income levels, and they pay a lot more in taxes to get their health care and other "safety social net" benefits. That's what "paying your fair share" really looks like. Ask yourself whether Americans are ready and willing to vote for this; ask also which politicians are speaking honestly in public about these facts.
Public healrhcare is better than no healthcare. Remove the middleman insurance company and costs of administrating denials, and total costs ate reduced by 50%. Add scale and costs per unit get cheap.
US companies spend something like US $2 trillion per year to provide this health insurance, and that's money that could be invested in products and services, or delivered as profit to shareholders. So I'm always wondering: Why aren't businesses in the US clamoring for the government to take over the responsibility and cost of providing healthcare? Wouldn't some kind of healthcare for all be an enormous benefit for US businesses?
Thank you for the excellent article. Insurers are making money but so are healthcare providers. There is a reason why all these universities are starting healthcare systems. For example, I just received a 10 minutes physical from a UCLA primary care doctor that cost $623. This is 3 times more than my prior solo practice doctor charged last year. Aetna just pays the money to UCLA Health and passes the costs along to my employer who passes the increased premiums to their employees. Big fat profits all around on the backs of employees with no incentive to bring costs down. Expansion of medicare is a practical step in the right direction.
I love the same reimbursement for procedure proposal and lowering age incrementally for Medicare. Unfortunately the only way this will happen is by reversing the seriously flawed Citizens United ruling. We need to also create more awareness of which hospitals are PE owned so people can actively boycott them due to higher risk of adverse outcome for patients at those locations. I just did a ChatGPT query for my county and am getting okay results that are at least better than nothing.
Obviously with 70% of us OBESE and 90% have CKM we will have to pay for medicine etc. But only 15% of the 70% take a GLP-1 and the Wellness Bitches want to get rid of these drugs so they can revel in "healthy." The latest: Chris TSAKALAKIS ECO of Eli Lilly Direct didn't know the obesity stats. In emails with him it appears he is unhappy to find that the market is almost twice as big as the FDA says. It's not 40% and he seems to wish it was! That's how sick we are.
Good post Scott. I have one word for you, and it isn't plastics. It's profits.
Everyone in the value chain is incented via TSR to increase volume and profit YoY. So the sicker we are the better, and because healthcare is non-negotiable, at some point (often too late to 'cost contain') it will continue to spiral.
We need a radical reboot and it was news to me that Congress has a hand in tamping down supply on the practitioner side. Their pockets must be being lined by all of the players in that value chain. As long as the only thing that matters in this country is getting rich, we're going to see things get worse for all but the few.
Two things I think you could include in your plan, Scott. You mentioned how many doctors like myself are not in primary care. A large part of this is the fact that we find it overwhelming to run practices in the setting of the current healthcare system. When we talk about collecting payments, I know there’s disparity, but you also have to remember that the amount of infrastructure it takes to get those payments as well beyond the ability of many primary care, doctors and smaller communities. Another key formed that we will have to come with all of this is tort reform. A lot of our expensive practice is defensive medicine and cannot be ignored any longer. There’s always love your posts and let me know if you ever want a beer in Denver.
As a Canadian, these all sound like nice problems to have. Only 25% of Americans have poor access to primary care? Almost none of us do. Need to see a specialist? Hope you don’t have a terminal situation as you’ll be waiting 18 to 24 months minimum…oh, and if you were referred to the wrong type of specialist or need to see a different one, stack those times up. The entire Canadian primary care ‘system’ is designed to gatekeep patients from putting any load on the specialist system….because there’s nil capacity. We pay the most and in turn receive pitiful results. Adding insult to injury, working in the system or knowing someone who does is the method of choice for queue jumping. At least the US system is transparent, you get what you pay for. In Canada, and I’m sure most other government run systems, there’s a facade of altruism that doesn’t survive actual experience. I’d trade any day.
Not sure what happened to the doctor shortage in my neighborhood since we now have more urgent care clinics and hospital-group primary care centers than we have Starbucks.
The shortage seems to be in independent practices that are drowned in insurance and billing paperwork and the associated clerical overhead to the point where the doctors can’t make a living unless they join a group that can centralize the business side of its many practices.
Medicare for All, like other government benefits, is quite popular until you ask people to pay for it with their own taxes instead of sending the bill to Notyou, Notme, or their own kids and grandkids. It might work fine for a while but - like today’s British NHS - it would be slowly starved to death by voters who insist on benefits but refuse to pay enough in taxes to properly fund them, and the politicians who pander to them.
I am constantly amazed at how you don’t just hit a nail on it head, you drive it all the way through! I pay that our politicians are as much of a fan as I am!
For all its bravado, America must be the most fearful country in the West. Insurance, immigration, (artificial) intelligence. A country kept in anxiety can’t be expected to stay healthy.
Great article. There's a huge issue with how people choose their health insurance, and the process seems designed to confuse the consumer. KFF found that 84% of Americans can't figure out what something will cost because they don't understand plan structures (deductibles, copays, allowed amounts, etc.).
Choosing the wrong employer-sponsored health plan can cost an individual thousands more in premiums and out-of-pocket costs. Across all our users, the wrong plan typically costs $4,339 more per year. And employers have an incentive to get everyone on the lowest-cost plan, whether or not it's right for the individual. Billions have been raised in recent years by companies that help steer employees toward the plans that cost employers the least (e.g., Nayya) or push them toward benefit programs unrelated to core insurance (e.g., Thatch).
We're building PlanStan (theplanstan.com), the first employee-aligned analysis tool, to solve this problem. It analyzes your options to find the one that actually costs you and your family the least. It uses hundreds of thousands of billing records to estimate usage and cost scenarios, then runs them through the real math and tax implications of each plan.
Next up for us is bringing more transparency to billing and pricing so people can be better consumers of healthcare.
There’s not much of a choice. I am given two options and asked to pick one. Insurance dependent on employment needs to go.
Open market plans are always an option but there have a much worse tax treatment. Employer sponsored plans can be paid with pre tax dollars, but not open market plans.
We need to kill Employer Sponsored Insurance (ESI). Anything else is just rearranging deck chairs. Medicare For All (M4A) is a good slogan - but we already know that Medicare pricing won't work - so the slogan is just that. A slogan.
https://danmunro.substack.com/p/why-we-need-to-end-employer-sponsored?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=8d11k
Pick your favorite AI agent and ask it to prepare a table. On the left (rows) have it list things like median household income, average marginal and effective tax rates at that median level as well as at other household income levels, say $70K, $125K, $300K, etc. Also rows for the % of taxes paid of the top 1%, 10% and, very importantly, the middle 50%; also ask what percent pay zero income tax. Along the right (the columns) have it list the US along with whatever countries you feel are providing better health care and lower cost. It will take you two minutes.
Spoiler alert: What you'll find is that, in those countries, everybody pays at nearly all income levels, and they pay a lot more in taxes to get their health care and other "safety social net" benefits. That's what "paying your fair share" really looks like. Ask yourself whether Americans are ready and willing to vote for this; ask also which politicians are speaking honestly in public about these facts.
Growing up, I remember my father saying "the insurance business is a license to steal." That was 50+ years ago. Plus ca change...
Public healrhcare is better than no healthcare. Remove the middleman insurance company and costs of administrating denials, and total costs ate reduced by 50%. Add scale and costs per unit get cheap.
US companies spend something like US $2 trillion per year to provide this health insurance, and that's money that could be invested in products and services, or delivered as profit to shareholders. So I'm always wondering: Why aren't businesses in the US clamoring for the government to take over the responsibility and cost of providing healthcare? Wouldn't some kind of healthcare for all be an enormous benefit for US businesses?
Thank you for the excellent article. Insurers are making money but so are healthcare providers. There is a reason why all these universities are starting healthcare systems. For example, I just received a 10 minutes physical from a UCLA primary care doctor that cost $623. This is 3 times more than my prior solo practice doctor charged last year. Aetna just pays the money to UCLA Health and passes the costs along to my employer who passes the increased premiums to their employees. Big fat profits all around on the backs of employees with no incentive to bring costs down. Expansion of medicare is a practical step in the right direction.
I love the same reimbursement for procedure proposal and lowering age incrementally for Medicare. Unfortunately the only way this will happen is by reversing the seriously flawed Citizens United ruling. We need to also create more awareness of which hospitals are PE owned so people can actively boycott them due to higher risk of adverse outcome for patients at those locations. I just did a ChatGPT query for my county and am getting okay results that are at least better than nothing.
Obviously with 70% of us OBESE and 90% have CKM we will have to pay for medicine etc. But only 15% of the 70% take a GLP-1 and the Wellness Bitches want to get rid of these drugs so they can revel in "healthy." The latest: Chris TSAKALAKIS ECO of Eli Lilly Direct didn't know the obesity stats. In emails with him it appears he is unhappy to find that the market is almost twice as big as the FDA says. It's not 40% and he seems to wish it was! That's how sick we are.
If you're interested, I am happy to discuss the often-unknown risks of PEO relationships with a member of your team.
You can find me on LinkedIn - Frank Pennachio
Good post Scott. I have one word for you, and it isn't plastics. It's profits.
Everyone in the value chain is incented via TSR to increase volume and profit YoY. So the sicker we are the better, and because healthcare is non-negotiable, at some point (often too late to 'cost contain') it will continue to spiral.
We need a radical reboot and it was news to me that Congress has a hand in tamping down supply on the practitioner side. Their pockets must be being lined by all of the players in that value chain. As long as the only thing that matters in this country is getting rich, we're going to see things get worse for all but the few.
But eventually, we ARE going to eat them!
Two things I think you could include in your plan, Scott. You mentioned how many doctors like myself are not in primary care. A large part of this is the fact that we find it overwhelming to run practices in the setting of the current healthcare system. When we talk about collecting payments, I know there’s disparity, but you also have to remember that the amount of infrastructure it takes to get those payments as well beyond the ability of many primary care, doctors and smaller communities. Another key formed that we will have to come with all of this is tort reform. A lot of our expensive practice is defensive medicine and cannot be ignored any longer. There’s always love your posts and let me know if you ever want a beer in Denver.
As a Canadian, these all sound like nice problems to have. Only 25% of Americans have poor access to primary care? Almost none of us do. Need to see a specialist? Hope you don’t have a terminal situation as you’ll be waiting 18 to 24 months minimum…oh, and if you were referred to the wrong type of specialist or need to see a different one, stack those times up. The entire Canadian primary care ‘system’ is designed to gatekeep patients from putting any load on the specialist system….because there’s nil capacity. We pay the most and in turn receive pitiful results. Adding insult to injury, working in the system or knowing someone who does is the method of choice for queue jumping. At least the US system is transparent, you get what you pay for. In Canada, and I’m sure most other government run systems, there’s a facade of altruism that doesn’t survive actual experience. I’d trade any day.
Not sure what happened to the doctor shortage in my neighborhood since we now have more urgent care clinics and hospital-group primary care centers than we have Starbucks.
The shortage seems to be in independent practices that are drowned in insurance and billing paperwork and the associated clerical overhead to the point where the doctors can’t make a living unless they join a group that can centralize the business side of its many practices.
Medicare for All, like other government benefits, is quite popular until you ask people to pay for it with their own taxes instead of sending the bill to Notyou, Notme, or their own kids and grandkids. It might work fine for a while but - like today’s British NHS - it would be slowly starved to death by voters who insist on benefits but refuse to pay enough in taxes to properly fund them, and the politicians who pander to them.
I am constantly amazed at how you don’t just hit a nail on it head, you drive it all the way through! I pay that our politicians are as much of a fan as I am!